What's Happening from Environmental Building News
USGBC to Offer Precedent-Setting “LEED Interpretations,” Along with CIRs
A process for providing precedent-setting rulings to project teams using the LEED rating system is under development at the U.S. Green Building Council (USGBC). The resulting “LEED Interpretations” process is to be unveiled in the Fall of 2010. The LEED Interpretations process will look a lot like the process for Credit Interpretation Rulings (CIRs) that was in place prior to July 2009, according to information provided to LEEDuser.com by Cara Mae Cirignano, a LEED specialist at USGBC. LEED project teams use the CIR process to check on whether they can earn a LEED credit in a specific circumstance that may not be anticipated by the LEED rating system. Previously, CIRs issued for one project could be found in a database and referenced for other projects. That CIR process was discontinued with the launch of LEED 2009, largely because USGBC handed off authority of the LEED certification process, including CIRs, to its sister nonprofit, the Green Building Certification Institute (GBCI). GBCI in turn handed the CIR process to outside reviewers (a move it is in the process of reversing—see “GBCI Takes Closer Control of LEED Reviews.”) With the authority over CIRs now so far removed from management of the LEED rating system itself, USGBC didn’t trust that a ruling made for one project should automatically be available to others. While they can still get a project-specific CIR for a $220 fee, project teams have lamented the inability to apply those rulings to other projects—even their own. Under the expected plan for LEED Interpretations, the current non-precedent-setting CIRs will continue. The interpretations will be layered on top, with the following features: • A LEED Interpretation may be related to a LEED prerequisite, credit, or a Minimum Program Requirement. • For a fee, a LEED project team will be able to request a precedent-setting LEED Interpretation. • USGBC staff and technical committees will review the LEED Interpretations. • The resulting LEED Interpretations will be offered by USGBC in a publicly available database. Forthcoming announcements on fees and response times along with further details are expected.
August 30, 2010
DISCUSSIONSReader-contributed comments related to USGBC to Offer Precedent-Setting “LEED Interpretations,” Along with CIRs - BuildingGreen.com. Comments are listed with newest at the top.
| Log in to add comments - Help with comments |
[ top of page ]
RELATED ARTICLES|
BuildingGreen.com: What's Happening - July 2010
|
[ top of page ]
RELATED CATEGORIESGREEN TOPICS
[ top of page ]
DISCUSSIONS
Andrew Graceffa
Sep 8, 2010 RELATED ARTICLES
GBCI Takes Closer Control of LEED Reviews
BuildingGreen.com: What's Happening - July 2010 RELATED GREEN DESIGN
|
More comments
Well, this seems on the surface to be a welcome development by USGBC to bring back the precedent setting interpretation process. But the next moment of truth will come via the fee structure they institute. Given their history, I would expect they will charge $400-500 for each precedent setting interpretation to differentiate from project specific CIRs.
While a high fee, its not without reasons. But the ideal scenario would be for the USGBC to reorganize the whole process into two categories: Permanent CIRs and Project Specific CIRs, no more administrative inquiries. Along with this simplification, I would like to see the USGBC drop project specific CIRs to $75-100. Will this happen? Probably not, given the large rise in fees in the past couple of years. But it should, in an exercise in fairness and clarity.