 |
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
What's Happening from Environmental Building News
September 1, 1998
R-Value of Straw Bales Lower Than Previously Reported
Much of the published information on the energy performance of straw-bale buildings is based on measurements done in 1993 by Joseph McCabe at the University of Arizona as part of his master’s thesis. McCabe used a “guarded-hot-plate” apparatus (procedure ASTM C-177-85) to measure heat flow through a single bale that was 23” (580 mm) wide by 16 1⁄2” (420 mm) tall. He reported R-values of 48.8 (RSI-8.6) for bale on edge and R-54.8 (RSI-9.7) for the bale laid flat. Thus he concluded that the insulating value is R-2.68 per inch (0.054 W/m°C) when heat flow is perpendicular to the orientation of the straws (bales stacked on edge) and R-2.38 per inch (0.061 W/m°C) when the heat flow is parallel to the straw orientation. These values were reported in EBN’s feature article on straw as a building material ( EBN Vol. 4, No. 3) and in many other publications. Follow-up studies conducted since 1993 have given widely differing results. In 1994 a thermal probe was used by R. U. Acton at Sandia National Laboratory to deduce the R-value of a 16 1⁄2”-wide (420 mm) bale as R-44 (RSI-7.7), which seemed to support McCabe’s findings, but this is considered a fairly primitive testing procedure. In 1996, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) constructed a bale wall that was stuccoed on the cold side and covered with gypsum drywall on the warm side. This test found the R-value to be only R-17 (RSI-3.0). On a per-thickness basis, this is just R-0.94 per inch (0.15 W/m°C). The explanation for this very low R-value, suggested researchers, was that an air gap resulted from the way the drywall was attached to the bale wall; this could have created convection currents in the wall, depressing the R-value....
To read the complete article, please login below.
This article is available to members of BuildingGreen Suite
Join now for access to the entire website.
Membership in BuildingGreen Suite gives you access to all of the product descriptions, articles, project case studies, and other content on BuildingGreen.com. Regular individual membership costs $199.00 per year, however many membership options are available.
More about the benefits of membership...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|