How about foil coated bubble wrap under radiant heated slabs? Does any of it really work?
FTC Cracking Down on False R-Value Claims
Large fines levied on companies making deceptive claims about R-values
Most of us want to do the right thing in improving the energy performance of our homes. We research energy-saving products like appliances and insulation. We search the internet or clip ads from the paper looking for products that will save us the most energy (and money). We look for the most R-value for the money. Well-meaning homeowners do this all the time.
But it turns out that in a troubling number of situations there’s a significant discrepancy between claimed and actual performance. With insulation materials, for example, exaggerated R-value claims became so rampant in the 1970s—when adding insulation to homes came into vogue following the 1973 oil embargo—that the government stepped in to regulate energy performance claims.
The threat of fines hasn’t been as successful as we might have hoped, as exaggerated claims have long continued. Some long-overdue legal actions against insulation companies in January 2013, however, may finally begin to rein in these scams.
The Federal Trade Commission Finally Doing Its Job
When R-value scams became common in the 1970s, the U.S. Congress passed legislation assigning the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to the task of policing R-value claims. The so-called “R-Value Rule” was adopted in 1979. That rule helped to some extent, but grossly exaggerated R-value claims have continued.
SUPPORT INDEPENDENT SUSTAINABILITY REPORTING
BuildingGreen relies on our premium members, not on advertisers. Help make our work possible.See membership options »
A $350,000 fine leveled against Edward Sumpolec, doing business as Thermalkool, Thermalcool, and Energy Conservation Specialists, on January 9, 2013 may cause insulation producers and installers to be a little more careful with their claims. These companies were selling both liquid-applied coatings and radiant-foil insulation materials.
According to a January 31, 2013 FTC press release, “Sumpolec’s advertising included false claims such as ‘R-100 paint,’ ‘This . . . reflective coating will reduce wall and roof temperatures by 50-95 degrees . . .’ and ‘Saves 40 to 60% on your energy bills.’” The U.S. Department of Justice, working on behalf of FTC, won the order on the merits of the case, without requiring a trial. This was the largest fine ever levied on an insulation company based on a violation of the FTC R-Value Rule.
Inflated R-value claims like Sumpolec’s are so blatantly obvious that most consumers won’t be duped by them. But there are many, many cases where the claims aren’t quite as over-the-top, and it’s very easy for reasonably smart consumers to be duped.
I don’t know how many calls I received over the years from friends and family members who are thinking of contracting to have their attics insulated with radiant-barrier insulation or radiant paint or extraordinarily high-R-value rigid insulation.
If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
It’s not just insulation
Exaggerated energy performance claims aren’t limited to insulation. I have often seen ads in our local newspaper’s weekend magazine for seemingly magic electric quartz space heaters, and one can find outrageous savings claims for fairly ordinary windows, exaggerated claims for the benefits of weatherizing services, and highly misleading claims about home-scale wind turbines.
There was even a class-action lawsuit against Honda Motors for unrealistic mileage claims with its Civic Hybrid (we’ve had ours since 2003 and just turned over 170,00 miles).
Share your examples of outrageous claims
Consumers deserve to have access to clear, accurate information on the energy performance of products they buy. And manufacturers who violate that trust deserve to be called out for their deceptive claims. I’d like to compile examples of these outrageous claims and then publicize them—somehow.
(I may have to let my lawyer weigh in on how aggressive I can afford to be in this campaign for truth in advertising.)
Send links to unrealistic energy claims by manufacturers or service providers to me directly, or post comments below.
Alex is founder of BuildingGreen, Inc. and executive editor of Environmental Building News. In 2012 he founded the Resilient Design Institute. To keep up with Alex’s latest articles and musings, you can sign up for his Twitter feed.
Published February 20, 2013 Permalink Citation
(2013, February 20). FTC Cracking Down on False R-Value Claims. Retrieved from https://www.buildinggreen.com/blog/ftc-cracking-down-false-r-value-claims
Foil coated bubble wrap.
Garage doors may be a good article opportunity for EBN
Thanks for your reply however, I beleive this coudl be an excellent lead for EBN. It would be a very good development if BG cracked the garage door story. It's not rocket science. all one has to do is look at the published r values of the manufactureres and do the math for the materials used. My students could do this. The values simply do not add up
It's an open and shut case.
Reporting false advertising claims
Consumer Reports regularly reports false and misleading advertising claims that readers send them. They don't specialize in building materials but would certainly be interested in anything with widespread consumer impact -- and they have lots of legal representation available if needed.
very encouraging.... overhead door companies should be next
Thank you.. This is very encouraging.... The next area for clarity are overhead door companies inflated claims that their foam fillled metal doors deliver R values approaching R10 per inch... They lack the folliowing"
- a uniform testing proceedure - it varies from mfg to mfg.
- There is no unit test for the door in the frame.
- Air infiltration must be accounted for in any serious energy consideration it is not for this industry.
- the metal doors lack a thermal break
Hope this helps...
Joseph Cincottta AIA
"Seriously" exaggerated claims
Serious Windows was actually implicated by FTC for exaggerated energy claims, as reported by our editorial intern Erin Weaver: http://www.buildinggreen.com/auth/article.cfm/2012/3/26/FTC-Cracks-Down-...
Add new comment
To post a comment, you need to register for a BuildingGreen Basic membership (free) or login to your existing profile.